Sustainability is increasingly fundamental to performance, helping reduce operating costs, manage risk and protect long-term value.
The challenge is data.
Take for example commercial real estate. Effective capital decisions depend on understanding asset-level sustainability performance and costs; that is, which properties are most energy- and emissions-intensive, where risks are elevated and where limited capital will deliver the most value. Utility consumption data is foundational to this analysis, yet it remains notoriously difficult to collect, manage, interpret and trust.
Teams spend scarce time mired in chasing information across various data sources, and gaps in quality and completeness undermine confidence in the insights. The result is significant effort spent managing data rather than acting on it, leaving its full value unrealized in consequential investment, operational and asset management decisions.
Technology is not a panacea
Enter technology. A proliferation of software, digital data management systems and artificial intelligence (AI)-enabled tools offer to close this gap by automating data collection, reducing reliance on estimates, improving data quality and generating better insights.
And while promising, technology is not a panacea. Gartner found that only 48 per cent of digital initiatives meet their targeted outcomes, while McKinsey found that organizations often capture less than one-third of their expected value. Success depends on nuanced goals and how well technology is integrated into the business. BCG found that strong strategy, leadership, talent, governance and employee adoption increase the likelihood of success from 30 to 80 per cent.
Too often, solutions fall short due to the following challenges:
- Unclear data needs: Without properly defining what data is needed and by whom, it is difficult to select and configure systems that provide decision-grade analytical outputs.
- Structural challenges: Separate data workflows, siloed teams, unclear governance and inconsistent reporting practices make it difficult to embed new systems across an organization.
- Insufficient resourcing: An underappreciation of how much ongoing effort is needed to deliver and maintain the system’s full value.
The data maturity journey
Before investing in new tools, organizations need a clear view of the path ahead. Quinn+Partners’ sustainability data maturity continuum plots this journey in four key stages:
- Fragmentation: Data collection initially relies on consolidating fragmented spreadsheets, email requests and manual data entry into a central tracking file. Responsibilities often lie solely within the sustainability function, and data is primarily used for reporting.
- Standardization: As organizations mature, they standardize data requests, use template tools and formalize processes and responsibilities in data management plans. Controls are established such that data outputs go through quality review and sign-offs. Outputs are manually shared between business functions.
- Adoption: Once organizations adopt digital data management systems, they begin to serve as a central source of truth. Multiple teams and external parties are given logins and asked to enter data directly, distributing the reporting effort and increasing efficiency. User actions are traceable and underlying invoices are stored with consumption records, simplifying data assurance. Summary dashboards and analytics become automatically generated.
- Automation: In this final stage, the data system is configured with direct connections to utility accounts. Data flows automatically. AI-enabled analytics allow for quick insights and increased user-friendliness. Integration and connection to enterprise data systems and workflows have been established for on-demand accessibility and use in investment decision-making.
Steps for effective implementation
Advancing along this continuum begins with a clear vision of how technology-enabled data can support sustainability and business objectives. It requires rethinking existing processes, establishing data governance, upskilling staff, managing organizational change and reshaping how cross-functional teams collaborate. We recommend following four steps:
- Conduct a diagnostic: Define data users, needs and criteria to measure success against. Assess current data workflows and key challenges. Determine the best digital solution(s) for your needs and map your ideal workflows. Develop a tailored implementation plan to drive progress.
- Obtain the right system: The market is saturated with third-party data systems. While they generally serve the same purpose, some have more distinct use cases such as regulatory reporting or operational optimization. Selecting the right system should be informed by your diagnostic and by involving data users for buy-in. In certain circumstances, a bespoke system is best for providing customized functionality and flexibility.
- Implement: This step is often the most significant time investment, but also the most crucial. It entails onboarding historical data, establishing asset configurations and utility automations, optimizing processes, developing standardized outputs, integrating into organizational systems and quality testing all results.
- Establish governance and change management: To support adoption and continued functionality, document final workflows with defined oversight and responsibilities. Develop training and roll-out plans bespoke to your various data users. Establish quality control processes and accountability mechanisms, and ensure ongoing support is in place.
Digital transformation does not happen overnight, but laying the groundwork now is essential to unlocking the opportunities that advanced analytics and AI can offer.
By following the steps above, organizations can build a strong foundation for scalable data systems that enable more informed management decisions.
